1. Define the job
We start by identifying the intended use and compare products against alternatives designed for the same category and audience.
2. Check evidence
Specifications should be verified against manufacturer documentation, while price and availability should be dated because they change frequently.
3. Evaluate trade-offs
Each review presents strengths and limitations together. A product can perform well overall and still be the wrong fit for a particular person.
4. Assign the score
The score summarises category-relative performance, usability, value, support and longevity. The written verdict and intended audience carry more meaning than a small numerical difference.
5. Date and correct
Every review displays its latest checked date. Material corrections should be made promptly and the date updated when the review is reverified.